When Peter Drucker coined the term MBO in his 1954 book titled The Practice of Management, little did he know that it would cause such a stir in the world of management. It is easy to understand the enthusiasm.
On paper, MBO makes a lot of sense!
The pivot of any business are its employees. Therefore, when Drucker suggested that involving them in setting business goals means they are more likely to share top management’s objectives, it was as if the Pandora’s box was suddenly opened and all these questions that were otherwise embedded in the silos of old management practices were suddenly out in the open.
But, what is MBO? Read more to find out!
What is Management by Objectives (MBO)?
To put it simply, Management by Objectives is a performance-based reward system in which managers and employees work in collaboration to set goals.
The genius of Drucker is commendable. Instead of coming up with complex management mantras, he set forth several easy principles that management could follow-
- Objectives are laid out on an individual basis by the management and the employee
- These objectives should be challenging but achievable
- Employees should ideally receive daily feedback
- The focus is on rewards rather than punishment
- Personal growth is emphasized
The aim of MBO is to align targets with the organization’s objectives, and team members earn based on how effectively they complete the goals defined in their individual MBO program.
Each employee's MBO plan should clearly define their tasks and workflows, and ensure that these goals are emphasized from day one.
While MBO looks perfect on paper, its performance has been skewed. A weakness pointed out by many critics is that this style of management places more focus on the setting of goals to attain objectives, but fails to provide a systematic plan to do so.
Prominent critics of the theory, such as W. Edwards Deming, argue that ‘setting particular goals like production targets leads workers to meet those targets by any means necessary, including shortcuts that result in poor quality.’
Therefore, streamlining the process of introducing MBO and following best practices becomes a top priority for most players.
A step-by-step guide for MBO optimization:
MBO optimization cannot be achieved overnight! Refer to these easy-to-follow steps that we’ve put together for you-
- Revise the organizational objectives for the entire company. This is basically a broad overview of what the company’s goals are and should be derived from the firm’s mission and vision.
- Translate the organizational objectives to employees. In 1981, George T. Doran used the acronym SMART (specific, measurable, acceptable, realistic, time-bound) to express the concept.
- Stimulate the participation of employees in setting individual objectives. After the organization’s objectives are shared with employees from the top to the bottom, employees should be encouraged to help set their own objectives to achieve these larger organizational objectives. This gives employees greater motivation since they have greater empowerment.
- Monitor the progress of employees. In step two, a key component of the objectives was that they are measurable for employees and managers to determine how well they are met.
- Evaluate and reward employee progress. This step includes honest feedback on what was achieved and not achieved for each employee.
Benefits of Management by Objectives:
The benefits of MBO include:
- Clarity of Goals: MBO helps to establish clear and measurable goals that are aligned with the overall objectives of the organization. This helps to create a sense of direction and purpose for employees, and ensures that everyone is working towards the same targets.
- Improved Communication: MBO requires regular communication between managers and employees, which helps to build stronger relationships and promotes open communication channels. This helps to foster trust and transparency, which in turn can improve employee morale and engagement.
- Increased Accountability: MBO helps to establish clear expectations for employee performance and provides a framework for holding employees accountable for meeting their objectives. This can help to create a culture of accountability, where employees take ownership of their work and strive to achieve their goals.
- Better Performance: MBO helps to improve employee performance by providing regular feedback and coaching on progress towards objectives. This helps employees to identify areas for improvement and to make adjustments to their work processes to achieve better results.
- Alignment with Business Objectives: MBO helps to align employee goals and objectives with the overall objectives of the organization, which can improve overall business performance. When everyone is working towards the same goals, the organization can achieve greater success and growth.
Overall, MBO can help organizations to improve communication, increase accountability, and achieve better results by setting clear goals and working collaboratively towards achieving them.
Disadvantages of Management by Objectives:
While MBO can be an effective approach to management, there are also some disadvantages to consider:
- Time-consuming: Implementing MBO can be a time-consuming process. It requires a significant investment of time and resources to set objectives, define tasks, and measure progress towards achieving those objectives.
- Focus on short-term objectives: MBO can sometimes result in a focus on short-term objectives at the expense of long-term goals. This is because MBO emphasizes the achievement of specific objectives within a certain time frame, which may not always align with the long-term strategic goals of the organization.
- Emphasis on quantifiable objectives: MBO emphasizes the need for objectives to be measurable and quantifiable. While this can be useful in some contexts, it may not be appropriate for all types of objectives. Some objectives, such as those related to employee satisfaction or creativity, may be more difficult to quantify.
- Potential for goal displacement: MBO can sometimes lead to goal displacement, where employees focus solely on achieving the objectives that have been set for them, rather than pursuing other important goals or tasks that may not be explicitly defined in the MBO process.
- Overemphasis on individual performance: MBO can sometimes lead to an overemphasis on individual performance at the expense of teamwork and collaboration. This can be particularly problematic in organizations where teamwork is critical to achieving success.
- Resistance to change: MBO can sometimes create resistance to change, particularly if employees feel that the objectives that have been set for them are unrealistic or unattainable. This can lead to a lack of buy-in from employees and a failure to achieve the desired results.
It is important to be aware of its potential disadvantages and to use it in a way that is appropriate for the specific context and goals of the organization.
MBO: Red Flags
- As MBO is focused on goals and targets, it often ignores other parts of a company, such as the culture of conduct, a healthy work ethos, and areas for involvement and contribution.
- Strain is increased on employees to meet the goals in a specified time frame.
- Employees are encouraged to meet targets by any means necessary, meaning that shortcuts could be taken and the quality of work compromised.
- If management solely relies on MBO for all management responsibilities, it can be problematic for areas that don’t fit under MBO.
Your Edge: Automation with Kennect!
A Management by objective program should be diverse and dynamic, and chances are that your employees will spend too much time writing emails and spreadsheets.
Kennect’s fully automated ICM solution leverages a data-driven approach to build, run and automate your incentive compensation plans to create transparency and achieve operational efficiency. This provides uniformity across all departments and sales regions, streamlines operations and practically eliminates the risk of human error impacting remuneration.
Book a demo with us today to learn more about how Kennect can help you optimize your MBO plans!
Top-Down Goals vs Bottom Up Goals: Which is Best for Your Sales Team?
How to Identify Your Company Objectives for Growth & Success
Maximizing Productivity: Benefits of Employee Incentive Programs
A Complete Guide to Execution Of Sales Performance Management